I happened to attend a meeting recently that had in attendance the district collector of a district in AP and MLAs belonging to the district. There was a discussion at the end of the meeting regarding the injustice meted out to some meritorious students by certain “corporate” colleges. The discussion got me thinking and some of the thoughts are presented below.
I have studied in AP for all my life except during my MBA. So, I am not sure if the flaws I have noticed are endemic to the state alone or are a common characteristic throughout the country. This is how the system basically works/worked. Most schools have a single-minded focus on one thing alone. Getting as many students they can in the class 10th top rankers list. So, the potential candidates are identified early. How early? As early as class 8th. The segregation begins as the entire strength in a class is divided into sections based on the performance of the students in say an entrance exam or based on their previous performance. The “top” sections are provided with the best teachers. They are focused upon and groomed as they are the keys to a goldmine. The thing here is that parents look at the top performers of a school before deciding to admit their kids into it. It doesn’t really matter if their kid is interested in or is really capable of securing a top rank.
So, while the toppers are taught by toppers, the other kids are under the custody of the second rung teachers. Capitalism is all about allocating resources to the people who will make the best use of them. But in fields like education this isn’t what is to be followed. If a kid is good at studies, he would be able to compete well enough even if the resources provided to him aren’t topnotch. But it is the kids who are usually not great with studies that need better resources. A level-playing field needs to be created. In fact, forget all that when your kid is being charged the same fee as the smart kid, he should have access to the same resources.
The bias plays a major role in the future as well. The top performers perform well in the class 10th exams and proceed to the +2 stage. Here all hell breaks loose. The toppers are given a “free seat” as they are again expected to top the various entrance exams. The rest of the pack shells out thousands of rupees for college and coaching. Again, the toppers are made to slog all day for 2 years under the guidance of the “best” lecturers. The others on the other hand are again served the leftovers. It just amazes me how mind-fucked thousand of parents must be to pour all their savings for availing the services of such cheap quality academicians.
The business model here is pretty straightforward. Thousand of dumb asses (read parents) will only look at the top rankers. It doesn’t matter if their kids can’t solve “2+2″, but they will pay thousands of rupees in fees for their kid’s college and coaching. They won’t really look at who is teaching whom at the college. If their kids fail, it’s the kids’ fault. The colleges are not to be blamed. Just look at the rankers list.
There is a reason why the toppers in school and junior college are usually the same. They have access to the best resources and moreover they are wired to study and perform well. But the kids who are not good are made even worse by the system. Access to inferior resources makes them far more inferior than they actually are. Due to this bias, they often end up in poor colleges after +2, resulting in serious economic disparities over their lifetime.
There is a very clear bias at the higher levels. IIMs prefer people from IITs/NITs over others. Some companies accept applications only from IITs/IIMs/ISB. The early differences are magnified over a period of time. Economic disparities occur not only due to differences in skill levels. There is a bigger systemic cause that needs to be addressed. Mind-fucked parents should realize that every penny spent on education should be worth the expenditure. Fight for access to the same resources as the smarter kids. Remember this, you may be the parent of a dumb kid, but never let the system make him dumber.